Edited to add a title I forgot.
While January may be short on titles, two of the books listed are quite long – Cutting for Stone at 658 pages and The Years Best Sci/Fi at 631 pages which took me all month to read, one story at a time. I started out the month with a couple of easy rereads, and then moved into a book I ordered through inter-library loan which I could not finish. However, I finished up quite strong which made it really hard to choose a best book (so of course I chose three for different reasons). If the quality of my reading stays this high it will be very difficult to come up with a “best of” list for 2011. And I am pleased to see that I have reviewed four of the books read so far and have two other reviews planned for Cutting for Stone and The Science Fiction collection.
- Reread: Ordeal of Innocence – Agatha Christie
- Reread: Murder at Hazelmoor – Agatha Christie
- Did not finish: Eurdition – Joyce Crawley
- Hypothermia – Arnaldur Indridason
- Cutting for Stone – Abraham
- The Wrong Blood – Manuel de Lope
- The Report: A Novel – Jessica Francis Kane
- Edited to Add: Hiroshima in the Morning – Rahna Reiko Rizzuto
- The Summer Book – Tove Jansson
- The Years Best Science Fiction: The Twenty-Seventh Annual Collection edited by Garner Dozois
Best Books: I read three really great books in a row and it is hard to choose a best among them – if I had to, I would pick The Report. It covers such complex issues while going into such detail about individual circumstances. For writing, I would pick The Summer Book because of Jansson’s evocative language and her ability to take the reader to the Island in Sweden as well as simultaneously letting the reader go back into their own memories of summer and grandmothers. But I can’t discount The Wrong Blood – it covers some of my favorite themes: secrets, memory, and the impact of the past on the present.
Best Travel Book: I would go with The Year’s Best Science Fiction, a collection of thirty-two of the year’s best science fiction short stories and novellas. It is heavy but there is something to appease you no matter what your appetite at the time. Himself got two collections for Christmas (Santa skipped a year) and reads the stories when he commutes to work on the bus. There is something for everyone in this collection from alternative history, steampunk, hard science fiction and some good old space operas.
Best Mystery: As much as I like Agatha Christie, I have to go with Hypothermia – a mystery with a quiet clarity. I also liked the back story of the main character, an Icelandic Detective.
Edited to Add: Best Non-Fiction: Hiroshima in the Morning. Of course it was the only non-fiction book I read but I finished it almost three weeks ago and I am still thinking and talking about it so it is hard to see what would have usurped it from this place. Hiroshima in the Morning is a memoir about a Japanese-American woman who leaves her family in New York for a six month fellowship in Japan. She is researching a novel and interviewing the survivors of the Hiroshima bombing. Along the way, she is dealing with a mother in ill-health, a husband who is very unhappy, cultural differences, and redefining herself. All this adds up to a lot of angst and soul searching as well as some fascinating (and at times, hard to read) interviews. The writing is very good but the book left me very unsettled. At times the author made me angry and at times I was sympathetic. I wondered a great deal if my reactions to the book were generational, cultural, or even sexist. I am very glad I read it and I think it is an important book – it speaks volumes about what countries to do each other, and what people do as individuals and most importantly, what we do to ourselves.
Do not bother: Eurdition. Somehow I caught notice of this book and was intrigued enough to hunt the book down through inter-library loan. It is the story of a mother and daughter; the mother with her past trying to prevent her daughter from making the same mistakes and the daughter trying to be as different from her mother as possible. I struggled through the first half. At that point, I went searching for my original reference to try and see what that person saw in the novel and I couldn’t find it at all. I don’t know if I wrote down the wrong book or what. At that point I saw no reason to continue. Eurdition seems to be a first novel self-published (?) by Joyce Crawley. Some of the writing was very good but it had a distinct feminist theme that I found too strident. If you are interested in a similar book, I highly recommend Elizabeth Strout’s first novel, Amy and Isabelle.